Interesting thread, especially for me as a newbie.
I am eager to catch a smoothhound, and it appears they are starting to show locally, so I will soon be buying some peelers. Having read about keeping them, and watching You Tube, I am a bit unsure about storing them though. This thread highlights the benefit of fresh over frozen, and yet elsewhere I see people freezing crabs as they peel to ensure they don't harden up.
Startfish sea fishing on you Tube advocates freezing them when they start to peel, so maybe contradicts the fresh over frozen argument.
I won't be buying loads so hope i can keep them alive for a couple sessions (say 3 or 4 days max), so should I not need to worry about freezing any?
If I don't want to be reliant on peelers being available, I'd like to maybe buy some frozen crab and keep so I am ready to go at any time. Again, any disadvantages?
Although yes, fresh is better, personally I’ve found hounds aren’t very discerning and will go for anything that remotely smells like a crab when they’re on the feed.
People do catch them on hardbacks too.
Ref frozen peeler, as long as it’s of a reasonable quality, it will still catch plenty.
I have literally caught 3-4 hounds on the same bit of crab, when the bait ran out, so that shows you they’re not too fussy!
In terms of keeping the fresh ones, I’m no expert but in the short term you should be okay keeping them somewhere cool and covering with a bit of damp weed.
Maybe spray with a little seawater every day. I wouldn’t keep them IN seawater.
You can keep them in the fridge too, that will slow the peel.
However... it depends how far along they are. If they’re literally popping out of their shells ie you can see the shell lifting off at the back, imo they’d need to be either used that day or frozen, otherwise you’ll end up with a softie and then a crinklie, as the shell hardens.
Hounds will happily go for softies too, but there’s more juice and smell in an actual peeler.
What you tend to find with a lot of the shop bought fresh ones, is yes they’re peelers, but they may ideally need a day or two or three to ‘bring them on’.
Only way to really tell is to take a crab and if you can’t see any shell lifting, gently squeeze the crab or try and pick a bit of shell off the back, to see if it’s crunchy or comes away easily.
If it all seems rock solid, the crab probably needs a couple of days at least.
The pull a leg joint off trick will tell you they’re peelers but not necessarily how far along.
I normally just buy frozen (if I can be fairly sure it’s a decent supplier) as I know where I am with the state of the bait and don’t have to faff with several crabs in various states of peel.
Someone like
@Valleyboy can probably better advise you on the care of fresh ones, as I must admit it’s not something I do too much of.